| Nick Di Croce, one of the facilitators for the Environmental Water Caucus, took a few verbal swipes at the controversial Bay Delta Conservation Plan (BDCP) during a public meeting in Sacramento on November 29.
Di Croce indicated that most of the environmental organizations that make up the Caucus are opposed to the proposed tunnels or any other peripheral conveyance intended to divert Sacramento River water under or around the Delta. He characterized BDCP as an "impending environmental and financial disaster whose costs and unsettled financing are going to bury the tunnel-oriented project."
He indicated that his organization has questioned the U.S. Department of Interior and the California Natural Resources Agency on what the real costs of fixing the Delta are, who is really going to pay for the project, and where the water is going to come from. Their questions have not been answered.
The Caucus also cited the three major factors that must be a part of any major Delta project. They are:
(1) A detailed analysis of how much water the Delta needs to be healthy and how much water is really available for export from the Delta;
(2) A valid cost benefit analysis to determine which projects should be undertaken; and
(3) A balancing of Public Trust values in order to protect the public's heritage and the ecosystem services of its streams and estuaries.
"A recent workshop conducted by the State Water Board has shown that legitimate claims to water flowing into the Bay Delta exceed the available water supply by more than five times in most years - which begs the question of whether there is more water available for BDCP. The refusal of the BDCP project to perform a legitimate cost benefit analysis is understandable; it will undoubtedly show the project is not to be able to pay for itself without inventing specious billions of dollars of guaranteed assurances," according to Di Croce.
"Similarly, not balancing public trust values is also understandable; that would show that the economic value of the services provided to the state and public by healthy, flowing rivers and estuaries far exceeds the value of water exports to a select few business enterprises south of the Delta," he said.
The Caucus recommends that the BDCP discontinue its proposed plan for tunnels and adopt a more sustainable and less expensive plan which has been presented to the Delta Stewardship Council by the Caucus.
Instead of the $14 billion tunnels, which will be buried before we get a chance to know if BDCP can work, the Environmental Water Caucus plan includes a more aggressive water conservation and efficiency program to more than make up for reduced exports, the elimination of irrigation water for impaired farmlands in the San Joaquin Valley, the installation of improved fish screens in the South Delta, the continuation of the Biological Opinions' pumping restrictions that have been helpful to the fisheries, the reinforcing of key levees in the Delta, and a series of related actions that will improve the ecology of the Delta and provide a higher degree of water supply reliability for farmers and urbans.
Details of the plan are described at http://www.ewccalifornia.org.
Members of the Environmental Water Caucus include AquAlliance, Butte Environmental Council, California Coastkeeper Alliance, California Save Our Streams Council, California Sportfishing Protection Alliance, California Striped Bass Association, California Water Impact Network, Clean Water Action, Desal Response Group, Environmental Justice Coalition for Water, Earth Law Center, Fish Sniffer Magazine, Foothill Conservancy, Friends of the River, Food & Water Watch, Granite Bay Flycasters, Institute for Fisheries Resources, The Karuk Tribe, North Coast Environmental Center, Northern California Council, Federation of Fly Fishers, Pacific Coast Federation of Fishermen's Associations, Restore the Delta, Sacramento River Preservation Trust, Sacramento Valley Environmental Water Caucus, Save the Bay Association, Sierra Club California, Sierra Club, SF Bay Chapter, Sierra Nevada Alliance, Southern California Watershed Alliance, Water for California and Winnemem Wintu Tribe .
Nick Di Croce, Co-Facilitator, Environmental Water Caucus
troutnk [at] aol.com, 805-688-7813
Mike Jackson, California Water Impact Network
mjatty [at] sbcglobal.net, 530-283-0712
Bill Jennings, California Sportfishing Protection Alliance
deltakeep [at] me.com, 209-464-5067
Mark Rockwell, Northern California Council, Federation of Fly Fishers
summerhillfarmpv [at] aol.com, 530-432-0100