cross-posted on Ruck Pad
Yesterday, we learned that Ellen Tauscher (CA-10) and a bunch of Blue Dog and New Democrats are heading to the White House on Friday to meet with Bush. There was a collective groan in the blogosphere. A few nay-sayers piped up in the comments, questioning why exactly it is a bad thing that Democratic Representatives meet with Bush.
Jane Hamsher reminds us of Bower's loyalty scorecard for 2005:
Out of the nine votes (the child interstate notification abortion act has since been added to the original eight) and the one proxy vote (I have also added Social Security to the totals via the Fainthearted Faction and Conscience Caucus collected by TPM) here are the current levels of party loyalty among different groups in the House:
All Democrats: 82.5%
All Republicans: 96.1%
DLC: 79.0%
Democrats, non-DLC: 83.3%
Blue Dog Democrats: 54.3%
Non-Blue Dog Democrats: 88.3%
Bingo. Caucus disunity has a name-o. Outside of the Blue Dogs, Democratic Party loyalty on the important, party differentiating votes in the House is comparable to Republicans: 88.3% to 96.1%. Further, Blue Dog Party loyalty, 54.3%, is massively lower than that found either in the DLC, 79.0%, or among non-Blue Dog Democrats, 88.3%. Overall, the thirty-five members of the Blue Dog coalition account for 44.9% of all Democratic Party defections over these ten votes / issues, even though they only make up 17.2% of the caucus.
Jane says:
Now it's quite possible nothing but tea and sympathy will be exchanged at this meeting with President Bad Ideas. But if there was ever a group of Democrats to worry about in this instance when it comes to creating problems for Nancy Pelosi in the upcoming legislative session, it doesn't take a lot of imagination to figure out who that might be.
Here in California we have our eye on one Representative in specific and that is Ellen Tauscher. There is no reason why she and the rest of the Blue Dogs/New Dems need to meet with Bush. We have party leaders who can do that for us. The new Congress is not even sworn in yet and already we have signs of a mutiny on our hands. We have our eyes on them and will hold them accountable.