[mobile site, backup mobile]
[SoapBlox Help]
Menu & About Calitics

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?

- About Calitics
- The Rules (Legal Stuff)
- Event Calendar
- Calitics' ActBlue Page
- Calitics RSS Feed
- Additional Advertisers


View All Calitics Tags Or Search with Google:
 
Web Calitics

Wire Services
Advertise Liberally Blue CA Ad Network

Confessions of a Not-So-Lifelong-Democrat

by: Lindsey Horvath

Mon Apr 04, 2011 at 17:59:43 PM PDT


I have a confession to make: I am not a lifelong Democrat. I did not wear a "Tiny Democrat" onesie while my dad marched with Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. My mom did not take me to CR groups. Admittedly, I think it would have been pretty fascinating to be that kid...but I wasn't.

Instead, I grew up in a conservative, Midwestern Catholic family, and I was instilled with a deep commitment to the ideas of family, faith, and freedom. My dad was the first generation in his family to go to college, and my mom was a homemaker who welcomed us home from school and made dinner every night. My faith shaped my commitment to treat others as I would want to be treated, and to be of service to those who are oppressed and in most need. My grandfathers served in WWII, and my uncles served in Vietnam and Korea, so I developed great respect for the service and sacrifice so many generations have made for my American freedoms.

Lindsey Horvath :: Confessions of a Not-So-Lifelong-Democrat
Naturally, when I was 18 and had the chance to register to vote in my first election, I chose the Party that professed a commitment to family values, God, and service to one's country. I joined the College Club for that Party and actively participated, as I believed it was my duty to be civically engaged. I was tired of hearing how young people didn't care, and I felt morally obligated to help people understand why voting was so important, particularly in that election.

As a Political Science and Gender Studies double-major, however, I received quite an education. I learned much more about my Party - that they did not stand by their stated commitment to education, to our aging population, or to our Christian mission to "help the least among us." I learned that they were, in fact, the most likely Party to advocate against the interests of low- and middle-income Americans; that they were selective in the families they valued; and that they were quite interested in preventing the advancement and equality of women in society. I learned that I was wrong about my Party - utterly and completely wrong.

So I changed my registration and became a Democrat. I felt an even greater responsibility to work hard and make sure people did not make the same mistake I had once made. I vowed that I would continue to work for all the values I had always held - protecting our environment, our working class, our seniors and ALL of our families; ensuring access to quality education and affordable health care; empowering women, gender minorities, and our youth.

For some people, however, this isn't enough. Recently, I ran in an election where my Democratic opponents suggested that my former Party affiliation spoke louder than my years of activism and accomplishment on a variety of progressive issues. I was expecting the attack; after all, when one runs for public office one has to assume that opponents will eagerly dredge up the past. But I found remarkable how many registered Democrats - and even some leaders within the Party - placed more value on my political indiscretion as an 18-year-old college freshman than on the decade-long promotion of progressive ideals that followed it.

These same attacks are being made against California Secretary of State Debra Bowen in her race for Congress, and against other non-lifelong Democrats like us, who work hard every day to advance the values of our Party. Even Secretary of State Hillary Clinton experienced a Democratic conversion in college: she was President of the College Republicans at Wellesley, and yet we do not place asterisks next to her accomplishments as First Lady, Senator, or Secretary of State because she registered with another Party decades ago. While we certainly value those who have made a lifetime commitment to the Party, the successful leadership of non-lifelong Democrats demonstrates that we are a Party committed to progress and that we believe change truly is possible.

When we effectively advocate for our issues, and we help people understand why they need to support Democratic values, we must welcome the converted as much as those baptized by the Party at birth. The Democratic Party is best served when we support people who are willing to do the work and fight for progressive values, regardless of when they joined. We cannot brand new Democrats with a political scarlet letter, thus engaging in the destructive politics of our opponents. We must set the example that political party conversion to becoming a Democrat is to be celebrated, much like the Parable of the Prodigal Son. Today, I take ownership of my Party affiliation and the values I represent as a member of it. As a Democrat, I value that we are "a big tent," welcoming to a diverse group of people who care about including and empowering those who have been disenfranchised. And I will work hard to make that tent as big as possible, so we can include all those who want to call the Democratic Party their home.

Tags: , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email

You wrote an essay praising George W. Bush (0.00 / 0)
The issue was not your previous affiliation with the Republican party, no matter how misguided.  The issue was your essay praising George W. Bush.  This shows a tremendous lack of mental faculty and judgment, which are certainly qualities one would seek in a member of the City Council.

Additionally, considering voters never got the vote for you the first time, and you were simply appointed, it would have been nice to answer unscripted voter-supplied questions the second time instead of relying on sound bites and hiding behind the other incumbents.


yeah, you know, FSM forbid (0.00 / 0)
that anyone make misguided choices based on the beliefs of their parents, and then realize the truth mid-way through college.  No...far better that your politics be handed to you through your parents.  That shows REAL judment.

Fail.


[ Parent ]
also, you created a calitics account (0.00 / 0)
just to bash Lindsey? That's some real desperation, but not surprising given a lot of the stupid vituperative crap that marked many of the attacks on the WeHo incumbents, particularly on Ms. Horvath.

[ Parent ]
I guess requesting that Lindsay actually talk to the voters makes me a troublemaker. (0.00 / 0)
That's a typically elitist (and Republican) attitude.  Of course once the voters finally got their say, they threw her out.  


[ Parent ]
she's a newcomer. It's a tough go (0.00 / 0)
But you guys didn't get your real prize, so best of luck to you going forward. The coming months will be fun! :-)

[ Parent ]
Here's a video of Lindsay running away from the press (0.00 / 0)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v...

It's a classic.  She never talked to voters at all or consented to interviews that weren't email questionnaires.  

Typical arrogance.  Just went to fundraisers and slobbered up to the rich.


[ Parent ]
Actually, that's patently untrue (0.00 / 0)
Lindsey did interviews over the phone or in person with all sorts of media outlets ranging from the New York Times to the West Hollywood Independent. Would you like a full list?

Also, I would dispute your characterization of Ryan Gierach as "press." You're talking about someone who chased Lindsey around a park with a video camera, called me a "dick" when I called him to correct a story he had written falsely claiming that John Heilman was not endorsed by the Stonewall Democratic Club, and most likely harassed me by calling me 15 consecutive times on my cell phone from a blocked number (I'm assuming it was him because I received five straight calls the next morning from a blocked number, that were followed up by a voicemail from him condescendingly saying, "you'd think a campaign manager would pick up his phone." That said, I have no 100% certain proof so I mitigate that claim with "most likely.")

Consequently, I would no more use the term "media" to refer to Ryan Gierach any more than I would use it to refer to Andrew Breitbart or James O'Keefe.

Ryan Gierach--as well as Patrick Range McDonald at the LA Weekly, who picked up on many of the false and misleading things Ryan wrote at WeHo News--had an overt political agenda of defeating Lindsey and her colleagues Abbe Land and John Heilman. Lindsey did not talk to them, likely for the same reason that Democrats avoid talking to Fox News. Little to gain, and everything to lose.


[ Parent ]
Are you the one who texted Lindsay the answers during her "debate" ? (0.00 / 0)
That went a long way to making sure she got tossed out.

[ Parent ]
Here's a cartoon of Lindsay buying her tickets to AbbeLand! (0.00 / 0)
[ Parent ]
that accusation is patently untru e (0.00 / 0)
and I have the phone records to prove it. Meanwhile, Lindsey had her phone in her purse the entire time. What you should be questioning is why the LA Weekly would resort to publishing the false allegations of an anonymous commenter whose sole intent was to smear a candidate he didn't like. You should also be questioning the integrity of the opposing candidates who said that Lindsey had her phone out (she didn't), and of Mito's campaign manager, who said that I was "texting furiously". Personally, I had no idea that four text messages during the course of 150 minutes of debate constituted furious texting.

Whoever you are, Yernar...the more you talk, the more of an embarrassment you make of yourself.


[ Parent ]
Wow. If you say it, it MUST be true. (0.00 / 0)
And any publication who writes truth that is inconvenient for you somehow is no longer "press" in your estimation. That is so Republican of you.  

And I don't know why you feel you must respond to every little statement of mine.   I can't believe this is what you do with your time.  How far you've fallen.

Of course now you will feel compelled to respond to me again.  Just to prove how "right" you are.



[ Parent ]
Totally Get It (0.00 / 0)
An education is a great thing, isn't it? I totally get this article. I grew-up in a deeply conservative town, myself, and I know what it's like to go through the process of questioning values that have been strongly instilled-- deeply conservative values--and coming out stronger, smarter and more independent for it. It takes a lot to go through that process--to go against family and community in some respects--and I have a lot of respect for those who manage to make that transformation in their youth. I myself wrote an essay condemning all use of pot and defended it adamantly my first year of college, before learning to think in other ways about that particular issue.

But that's what college is for, right? Thanks for supporting education, Lindsey, and let's hope you and our fellow Dems will make sure children today don't lose that opportunity!


Big tent anybody? (4.00 / 2)
Personally, I dropped my Libertarian registration in 2003 so I could be sure I could vote for Howard Dean. That didn't stop me from running as chair of the California Democratic Party in 2009. And nobody ever mentioned how recent my re-registration was. Of course, that could be because nobody considered me a viable candidate. Which was true.

But the fact is that I only registered Libertarian because I was disgusted with Democrats and Republicans alike. I didn't see anybody working for people like me. And DTS registration wasn't available back then in the dark ages.

I usually voted Democratic. But it wasn't until Dean convinced me that I might be able to change the Democratic Party that I really got involved. I thought it would be great if the Democrats really became the people's party. I have to say the effort has been frustrating. It has had its ups and downs. But I've never had anybody say I didn't belong in the Party, never had anybody reject my service, and--except for the one guy at my first state convention who yelled at me because I support reproductive rights and said "people like you are why we lose elections"--I've never had anybody tell my there was no place for my opinions. I don't always agree with Democrats. I think some of them are wimps, and others are sellouts. But I'm glad they let me into the Party because I'm a long way from finished trying to make it better.


Out of curioisity (0.00 / 0)
Why Libertarian?  Why didn't you register Green or P&F?  

[ Parent ]
Bowen's "manufactured" message (0.00 / 0)
It seems as though some misguided volunteers of the Bowen effort are trying very hard to create a "backlash" against Councilwoman Janice Hahn in lieu of Bowen's poor performance this weekend with rank & file party members.

Hahn came within 3 votes of securing the Democratic Party's endorsement against an individual who's represented a great part of the 36th in the California legislature for over a decade!

The fact is Councilwoman Janice Hahn is a born & bred Angeleno and lifetime Democrat!

To many voters, that is meaningful.

Her father was a county supervisor and former councilman, her uncle a councilman and her brother city attorney and mayor.

That's a long lineage of public service from one family!

The Bowen campaign seems to suffer from political amnesia in their attacks on Marcy Winograd's residency by several of their supporters as well as continued attacks on Winograd in this obsession of trying to shake the hard reality that Bowen is clearly the centrist, and most politically aligned with Jane Harman than any other Democrat in this race!

When you support WAL-MART, take donations from Enron, support the death penalty, author "three strikes" legislation and support the death penalty, it's hard to paint yourself a progressive with some 40 days til the election.


Self Entitled (0.00 / 0)
...The fact is Councilwoman Janice Hahn is a born & bred Angeleno and lifetime Democrat!...

,,, and a Self entitled office holder

Just Say NO to NEPOTISM !!!

Why elect another Corporate Democrat ??

...Before her election to the Los Angeles City Council, Hahn served as Public Affairs region manager at Southern California Edison; Vice President for Prudential Securities in Public Finance; Director of Community Outreach for Western Waste Industries; and Director of Marketing for the Alexander Haagen Company...

Sounds like a CORPORATE FLACK to me

...Public Affairs region manager at Southern California Edison;...

REALLY ??
Did she Flack to benefits of ENERGY DE-REGULATION ??
Wasn't THAT HER JOB ???


[ Parent ]
This is really low grade stuff (4.00 / 1)
You are provoking me to work for Bowen.  If that was your intent, congratulations.

I do agree with you that Bowen should have had the foresight to be born the daughter of a great politician.  That older generation of Hahns was impressive.  The current generation of Bowen is as impressive.


[ Parent ]
Debra Bowen's Republican appeal & Lindsey Horvath's pro-Bush essays (Horvath, like Bowen, is a former Republican) (0.00 / 0)
(1) Are Democrats now a party with members that want to -- because of the new open primary effected by Prop 14 -- curry favor and run Congressional more conservative candidates that appeal to Republican voters?  Is this what we are becoming?  Center-right Democrats who -- in order to capture Republican votes -- must now seek former Republicans who do not and will never fight the good fight for working class labor and harder edged Democratic core issues?

(2) Re, Lindsey Horvath's pro-Bush essays & former Republican registration (and certain bloggers'
posts re Bowen's Republican appeal), Former Councilwoman Horvath was indeed a a registered Republican who was appointed in 2009 to fill a vacancy  after the death of West Hollywood Councilman Sal Guarriello.   She lost her election bid because voters viewed her as fundamentally non-empathetic and as a businesswoman with strong Republican leadings. Bowen is a step removed from that, at best.  I'm fighting for Marcy Winograd to win this May 17th because she is the one true progressive in this race who represents real change and who will fight for working class Americans.  She is a solidly antiwar and pro-labor Democrat that voters can trust and can believe in.  She won 41% last June against Jane Harman and -- with your help -- will win the #1 or #2 spot in the open primary this May 17th.  For more information, please see below and http://www.peterthottam.com/wi...

- Pete
Venice for Real Change
http://www.peterthottam.com/wi...


Bowen's Republican appeal??? (0.00 / 0)
Peter, you're as out of touch here as you are on the progressive caucus listserv.

Lindsey's post speaks to the implications of Hahn's campaign that she's a better Democrat because she's been one all her life, as opposed to Bowen, who has only been a Democrat for 30 years (not good enough for some people, I guess). This has nothing to do with appealing to Republicans. This has to do with certain Democrats ostracizing other Democrats because they "converted" as opposed to being born that way.

If you knew Lindsey at all--which you clearly don't--you would know that she was and is a champion of equal rights for women and the LGBT community; was instrumental in ensuring that new hotels in the City were built with project labor agreements that would secure a living wage, and was strongly supported by UNITE-HERE and the Labor Fed because of her work; took the lead on West Hollywood's Climate Action Plan; wrote the resolution making West Hollywood the first city in California to boycott Arizona in response to SB1070; the list goes on and on, and her activism will continue far past her work on the council.

Her loss had absolutely nothing to do with "conservative leanings." For you to say that shows that you know nothing about her or about the race.

I understand that you're trying to support Marcy, but you're going about it all wrong here, just as you are on the listserv. Incorrectly attacking people you don't know is no way to win friends and gain support for your candidate.


[ Parent ]
Calitics in the Media
Archives & Bookings
The Calitics Radio Show
Calitics Premium Ads


Support Calitics:

Get discounted bestsellers at Barnes & Noble.com!

Advertisers


-->
California Friends
Shared Communities
Resources
California News
Progressive Organizations
The Big BlogRoll

Referrals
Technorati
Google Blogsearch

Daily Email Summary


Powered by: SoapBlox